E-letter concerning the consistency of the cultural sequence in "Supplementary Materials for Two Thousand Years of Garden Urbanism in the Upper Amazon"

Fausto Sarmiento; Florencio Delgado; Patricia Mothes; Guillerme Mongelo; Elmo León; Jonathan Panimboza; Lua Solomón; Marcos Michel; Ana Guachamín; Fernando Astudillo; Nicolás Dallasta; Alex de Barros; Jorge Gómez; Josefina Vásquez

E-letter concerning the consistency of the cultural sequence in "Supplementary Materials for Two Thousand Years of Garden Urbanism in the Upper Amazon"

Fausto Sarmiento
, Florencio Delgado
, Patricia Mothes
, Guillerme Mongelo
, Elmo León
, Jonathan Panimboza
, Lua Solomón
, Marcos Michel
, Ana Guachamín
, Fernando Astudillo
, Nicolás Dallasta
, Alex de Barros
, Jorge Gómez
, Josefina Vásquez

Pontifical Catholic University of Ecuador

Research output: Contribution to journal › Letter › peer-review

Abstract

The article "Two thousand years of garden urbanism in the Upper Amazon" ( 2)
sparked our interest, and after a close examination we have serious concerns
about inconsistencies between the text narrative and the supplementary data
offered to support the claims. We found serious flaws in the data, as well as in
how the data is analyzed in the article.

Original language	English
Journal	Science
Volume	383
Issue number	6679
State	Published - 2 Jul 2024

Access to Document

https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adi6317

Cite this

Fausto Sarmiento, Florencio Delgado, Patricia Mothes, Guillerme Mongelo, Elmo León, Jonathan Panimboza, Lua Solomón, Marcos Michel, Ana Guachamín, Fernando Astudillo, Nicolás Dallasta, Alex de Barros, Jorge Gómez, & Josefina Vásquez (2024). E-letter concerning the consistency of the cultural sequence in "Supplementary Materials for Two Thousand Years of Garden Urbanism in the Upper Amazon". Science, 383(6679). https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adi6317

@article{373c3792590d46c4a1d1f0ec6036c2bf,

title = "E-letter concerning the consistency of the cultural sequence in {"}Supplementary Materials for Two Thousand Years of Garden Urbanism in the Upper Amazon{"}",

abstract = "The article {"}Two thousand years of garden urbanism in the Upper Amazon{"} ( 2) sparked our interest, and after a close examination we have serious concerns about inconsistencies between the text narrative and the supplementary data offered to support the claims. We found serious flaws in the data, as well as in how the data is analyzed in the article.",

author = "\{Fausto Sarmiento\} and \{Florencio Delgado\} and \{Patricia Mothes\} and \{Guillerme Mongelo\} and \{Elmo Le{\'o}n\} and \{Jonathan Panimboza\} and \{Lua Solom{\'o}n\} and \{Marcos Michel\} and \{Ana Guacham{\'i}n\} and \{Fernando Astudillo\} and \{Nicol{\'a}s Dallasta\} and \{Alex de Barros\} and \{Jorge G{\'o}mez\} and \{Josefina V{\'a}squez\} and \{Y{\'e}pez Noboa\}, \{Alden Mauro\}",

year = "2024",

month = jul,

day = "2",

language = "English",

volume = "383",

journal = "Science",

issn = "0036-8075",

publisher = "American Association for the Advancement of Science",

number = "6679",

}

Fausto Sarmiento, Florencio Delgado, Patricia Mothes, Guillerme Mongelo, Elmo León, Jonathan Panimboza, Lua Solomón, Marcos Michel, Ana Guachamín, Fernando Astudillo, Nicolás Dallasta, Alex de Barros, Jorge Gómez & Josefina Vásquez 2024, 'E-letter concerning the consistency of the cultural sequence in "Supplementary Materials for Two Thousand Years of Garden Urbanism in the Upper Amazon"', Science, vol. 383, no. 6679. <https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.adi6317>

TY - JOUR

T1 - E-letter concerning the consistency of the cultural sequence in "Supplementary Materials for Two Thousand Years of Garden Urbanism in the Upper Amazon"

AU - Fausto Sarmiento

AU - Florencio Delgado

AU - Patricia Mothes

AU - Guillerme Mongelo

AU - Elmo León

AU - Jonathan Panimboza

AU - Lua Solomón

AU - Marcos Michel

AU - Ana Guachamín

AU - Fernando Astudillo

AU - Nicolás Dallasta

AU - Alex de Barros

AU - Jorge Gómez

AU - Josefina Vásquez

AU - Yépez Noboa, Alden Mauro

PY - 2024/7/2

Y1 - 2024/7/2

N2 - The article "Two thousand years of garden urbanism in the Upper Amazon" ( 2) sparked our interest, and after a close examination we have serious concerns about inconsistencies between the text narrative and the supplementary data offered to support the claims. We found serious flaws in the data, as well as in how the data is analyzed in the article.

AB - The article "Two thousand years of garden urbanism in the Upper Amazon" ( 2) sparked our interest, and after a close examination we have serious concerns about inconsistencies between the text narrative and the supplementary data offered to support the claims. We found serious flaws in the data, as well as in how the data is analyzed in the article.

M3 - Letter

SN - 0036-8075

VL - 383

JO - Science

JF - Science

IS - 6679

ER -